« ITV breaks the Daisy chain | Main | An open letter to the Mayor »

07/05/2008

Comments

Mo

Brilliant article.

Gordon Calver

I work in the financial sector in the city of London and I must say there are plenty of opportunities for black people to have a successful career and make lots of money. I can only assume the lack of opportunities in TV must be due to it being a racist industry. Tut tut I thought we had come a long way in this country, obviously not as far as we had all hoped. I guess it must be the same for the chinese, indians and all other ethnic groups who are unable to have a successful TV career and make lots of money.

Rakhee

"I think too many of us just accept this type of ethnic exclusion but it's up to us as people of colour to do something about it and work to make a change. Combined ethnic minorities are a very powerful consumer force and money talks."

Spot on - it's definitely a 2-way street. Great to see people succeeding in their ambition which is what everyone should do, regardless of background. Just a shame her dreams couldn't be realised here - something the media sector really needs to pay attention to if we want to stop losing talent.

Hopefully things will change with the time and efforts of more people in the sector.

Hauwa

Good article. Straight to the point and this problem is not only in the media, but in Management positions all over.

Dipper

"In Britain, the media bosses and commissioning editors have mental shackles. Do they trust whether a black woman would connect with their viewers? I doubt it."

err ... Trisha Goddard? Moira Stewart?

Alistair

This is so true and sad. There are so many british black actors who had only bit parts in the UK but have moved to the states and now have major roles in shows such as the wire. Why doesnt this happen here? Yes we have a lot of youth television black/asian presenters but thats all. Im not saying we expect ethnic minorities in every programme but why is America only recognising our talent? All we get is Ant and Dec over and over again. I'm 34 years old, born and raised in this country and still dont feel a apart of it or represented. God knows how the youths feel.

miguel vargas

Do not forget Julie Dorne Brown, also known as Downtown Julie Brown (born August 27, 1963), is a Welsh-born actress and former MTV VJ.Brown's father was Jamaican and her mother was English. She was a popular prsenter in the Late eighties/early nineties on MTV in the USA

Peter

"Great to see people succeeding in their ambition which is what everyone should do, regardless of background. Just a shame her dreams couldn't be realised here - something the media sector really needs to pay attention to if we want to stop losing talent."

I think you miss understand the distribution of 'talent' among people hoping for a job in the media. There is a massive over supply of people wanting a job in the media. At any point in time there are more students studying Media Studies at UK University's than are employed in the entire UK Media Industry. There will never be work for 95% of hopefuls wanting a job in the industry. The fact that Carpenter got a job in the US is remarkable and probably down to her excellent education and English accent - and the same reason so many British actors and actresses end up there.

Richard

America has more opportunities for everybody, not just minorities as mentioned in this article. Unlike Britain's class-riddled, inward-looking and negative culture, in the dynamic and forward-looking environment here people are mainly interested in what you can do, rather than what school you went to. I have been wildly more successful here than I was back in the UK, where my Northern accent held me back.

Christopher King

Well on my TV almost all the weather girls and the roving news reporters seem to be asian. So much so that I am surprised when I see a white one. Not so many black people admittedly, but then no chinese either. Does it matter ?

david

"Unlike Britain's class-riddled, inward-looking and negative culture..."
Posted by Richard.

I think that the problem goes way beyond race, after all historically african americans have been horribly oppressed in the US, and many are as disadvantaged as Britain's own minorities.

In my opinion, it is our culture of low expectations, our unbreachable class boundaries, our hatred of success, and our inability to think for ourselves except very narrow and prescribed ways, which act together to stifle any worthwhile individual endeavour.

Good luck Rob, and don't look back...

Nasser Aziz

Please note that Sharon Carpenter is a presenter on BET - Black Entertainment Television. I lived in the US for seven years and realised that the main channels wanted presenters that represented their audience...white middle class people. Sharon is a black presenter on a black channel so to say that America offers more opportunities for minorities is wrong. The US is one of most racially divided countries I have ever visited and rarely do people of colour appear on main stream television.

damian hockney

Sorry but I just do not buy this argument. While in the US, I've been helping to monitor a bit of news coverage at local and national level in the US for a friend who is campaigning for one of the presidential candidates. Not for the race of the newsreaders and presenters of course, but it is fairly obvious if I just do a run through of the programmes I've had to view. If I compare a typical local news programme with, say BBC London News, there is just no comparison. There are far more more black and other minority faces on the BBC programme. And Sharon is on BET. She's not doing NBC News. In fact, if you are going to make a point about race and presenting, to me she looks remarkably white for a black programme...this is a complex and tricky area and the article is frankly too simplistic and too keen to make a political point. Go tell it to African Americans whose unemployment rate is double that of white Americans.

hope

This was a fantastic article and so true to life and experience of many ambitious hard working and well deserving black people here in UK. A great encouragement too to look at the wider picture and not allow yourself to be held back.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.